It's been a week since I saw "Waiting for Superman" and I just have so much to say. I will try to compartmentalize my thoughts and narrow my focus in this entry.
First and foremost- I recommend this movie to EVERYONE.
I went into the theater with a bit of fear. I had heard some things about it already and was afraid it would just show all these extreme cases that do not represent the real issues but glorify those rare instances. It was not the case. Everything I saw, I knew with the exception of some of the national stats (we kind of hone in on California statistics). The movie did not cover everything to cover- it couldn't. What it did show is a chunk of an area of the flaws in our system. Every argument I have heard is something the movie did not include..."what about this?" and "what about that?" The fact that so many respected educators and non educators are asking these questions shows that there are many issues and that really, no one knows where to begin.
I woman in DC began by coming in and cleaning house- firing principals and closing down schools and proposing other ways to deal with tenure. She was shot down by the union and was actually just fired last week by the new mayor. She had the guts to make change and was not popular for it and didn't have the backing she needed to move forward.
Our students are not performing as they should and we need to fix that. No, the movie did not address the troubles our kids have today (family life, gang life, abuse, etc.) but we have to start somewhere. A kid may start a year behind grade level, but that teacher should be able to move that student forward in some way- and not all ways are testable by the state. We cannot control what a student's personal life entails, but we should be able to control who educates our kids. I have worked on 3 campuses now. At each place I could list a handful of teachers who simply should not be there. This is NOT ok. That is too many. People have argued that there are bad jobs being done in all professions. That is not a good argument! Those people shouldn't be there either! If we could get rid of the percentage of ineffective teachers, I believe a huge shift would happen.
Everything in the movie is true. The only itch I have is that charters are the only way to go. Only 20% of charters are more successful than public schools. We need to examine ONLY those successful schools and not just the idea of "charters" in general.
This film is designed to show us the flaws in the system. Educators are just as fed up with these issues as everyone else. It needs to change. I can say this to anyone who sees the film and has questions about public schools:
1. There are schools and districts that are successful. When I walk around my own campus I am among colleagues who share a passion and work ethic for these kids. In the film one man says, "There are so many good teachers out there. This is not who we are talking about. Walking into a room and seeing a good teacher is like seeing a pro athlete. It's magical." Most educators that I have worked with are effective in the classroom, especially my teaching partner who could teach all of us a thing or two about how to move kids forward. Those who are not, can be detrimental.
2. We all want change. Our kids deserve the best that there is.
3. So many good things are happening but these issues in the film are failing some kids. "Some kids" are too many.
4. Teachers affect lives in so many ways. Think of your favorite teacher. Was s/he your favorite because you got your highest state testing scores in his/her class? No. It was something else. We need to find other ways to evaluate student progress. State test scores are only one piece of evidence.
5. Visit the public schools you are considering for your own children. Do not just read the paper and see how they compare. Walk on the campus, meet with the pricipal, get a feel for the culture there.
I could really discuss this for hours and I already have. I love the debate and questions and thoughts. I am so glad this movie came out. People need to know what's happening so that change can be made.
Cheers to all the amazing educators out there!!!